Grandmother wins case to have grandchildren placed in her care

A grandmother who took over the care of her three young grandchildren five years ago wept as the High Court granted her application to direct Tusla to apply for orders formally placing the children in her care.

Grandmother wins case to have grandchildren placed in her care

A grandmother who took over the care of her three young grandchildren five years ago wept as the High Court granted her application to direct Tusla to apply for orders formally placing the children in her care.

Mr Justice Charles Meenan's judgment addressed the State's constitutional duty to intervene to protect children when parents fail in their duties in that regard and, in particular, Tusla's duty under the Child Care Act 1991 to protect children.

Represented by Michael Conlon SC, the grandmother went to court in July 2017 due to fears her daughter, who has many difficulties, would move to take the children back which the grandmother could not prevent because she has no formal legal right to retain them in her own care.

The children are at a very vulnerable stage in their lives and need Tusla's protection, she said.

The proceedings were initiated after Tusla failed to apply, despite several requests, for care orders on her behalf. In opposing her action, Tusla said it had no legal obligation to intervene.

It said the children were being cared for under a private care arrangement between the grandmother and the children's mother and, as far as it was concerned, the file on the case was closed as it had no current child protection or welfare concerns about them.

On Thursday, Mr Justice Meenan said the children's mother continues to suffer from addiction, mental health problems and other difficulties, remains incapable of looking after the children and is also in a "dysfunctional and abusive" relationship with her current partner.

Following an emergency case conference with Tusla in 2013, the grandmother agreed to take over care of the children in light of the then "significant imminent risk" to them.

This was an "enormous commitment" by her, involving her leaving her home and job and moving to another part of the country.

Tusla put a child protection plan in place which involved, among other things, the grandmother becoming the children's temporary carer and providing, if the mother was deemed able to parent them, there would be a gradual transition to her care.

There has been no formal review of the plan since April 2014 despite issues having arisen which the grandmother feared impinged on the children's safety and welfare, he said. These included District Court applications by the children's mother in 2016 and 2017 seeking guardianship and unsupervised overnight weekend access during which the mother alleged, among various claims, she had not agreed to the current arrangement relating to the children.

While the 2017 application was dismissed on technical grounds, there could be a further application, the judge noted.

Those applications by the mother underlined the vulnerable legal situation of the grandmother and cannot be of benefit to the three chidren who have significant childcare demands, he said.

Noting letters from the grandmother's solicitor setting out her concerns were not replied to and said he would have thought, at a minimum, a case review would have taken place in response to those.

He accepted the children's position is as set out by the grandmother and said Tusla's failure to review the position in some four years means it cannot validly dispute that.

It thus appeared the children require, within the meaning of Section 16 of the 1991 Act, "care or protection" they are unlikely to get unless a formal care or supervision order was made for them, he said.

In the circumstances, the grandmother was entitled to succeed, he ruled.

The case was adjourned to next week to allow the sides consider what formal orders should be made arising from the judgment.

more courts articles

Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother Man (25) in court charged with murdering his father and attempted murder of mother
Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van Man appears in court charged with false imprisonment of woman in van
Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman Man in court over alleged false imprisonment of woman

More in this section

National Risk Assessment for Ireland Tánaiste urges Israel ‘to show humanity’ and allow more aid into Gaza
Lego set based on RNLI lifeboat could soon become a reality Lego set based on RNLI lifeboat could soon become a reality
Travel Stock - Geneva - Switzerland UN human rights body calls for repeal or amendment of Troubles legacy laws
War_map
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited