Transfer rule change would help city clubs

Freemount’s delegate to the Cork County Board, John O’Flynn, believes that motions relating to transfers at tonight’s annual convention could provide city clubs with an unfair advantage.

Transfer rule change would help city clubs

Freemount’s delegate to the Cork County Board, John O’Flynn, believes that motions relating to transfers at tonight’s annual convention could provide city clubs with an unfair advantage.

O’Flynn, an assiduous examiner of the dealings of the board over the past number of years, fears that the motions — brought by the county committee — to amend transfer bye-laws would be disastrous for rural intermediate and junior sides.

It is proposed to reduce the ‘sitting out’ period of players seeking transfers from 96 weeks to 48 as well as the changing of the wording “family residence” to “permanent residence”.

“Back in 1972, Passage brought in this motion after John Horgan had transferred from Passage to Blackrock.

“This motion played a big part in stopping the transfer of talented players from junior and intermediate clubs to the city clubs.

“The ‘big thee’ senior hurling clubs of Blackrock, Glen Rovers and St Finbarrs have won 84 county senior hurling championships but only 10 between them since Midleton’s breakthrough in 1983 and five in the last 20 years.

“There is no doubt that the change in the transfer rule, where a player had to remain idle for 96 weeks to transfer, was one of the reasons why the dominance of the big three ended.

“There are two transfer motions for convention on Saturday night which could be of huge benefit to senior clubs, particularly those in the city. The first motion is that a player can transfer to the club where he has a permanent residence. Previously, he could only transfer to the club where his family resided. This means that a player who resides in Cork city for work purposes can transfer to any club in the city. The second is that a player can transfer to any club of his choice once he is idle for 48 weeks.

“One of the arguments being made is that it should benefit our senior intercounty teams by giving players in junior and intermediate clubs an opportunity to develop by playing senior club hurling. This could, however, have a devastating impact on the small junior and intermediate club, many of whom are struggling for numbers…

“If this is passed, a player who is idle for a year because of a long-term injury such as a cruciate or travelling abroad can go to whatever club he wants when he returns”.

O’Flynn also has difficulty with the concept of a player’s “permanent residence”, as laid down in the rulebook.

“I accept that the definition of family residence has to change, even though it will facilitate the transfer of players from rural clubs to the bigger urban areas,” he says.

“However, I don’t think that utilising the Official Guide’s definition of ‘permanent residence’ is appropriate as it allows the county committee to assess the ‘permanent residence’ of a player one month after the player has moved into it. I would consider that a much longer period of time should have elapsed before determining the player’s permanent residence or otherwise it could be open to abuse.

“I fear for the future of rural clubs if both these motions are passed on Saturday night.

“Once one or two players decide to jump ship, it will encourage others to do so. The result will be that the strong will get stronger and the weak will get weaker.”

more courts articles

Laurence Fox ordered to pay €210,000 in libel damages Laurence Fox ordered to pay €210,000 in libel damages
Former DUP leader Jeffrey Donaldson arrives at court to face sex charges Former DUP leader Jeffrey Donaldson arrives at court to face sex charges
Case against Jeffrey Donaldson to be heard in court Case against Jeffrey Donaldson to be heard in court

More in this section

John Cleary 20/4/2024 Tailteann Cup permutations: Cork set to be fourth seeds in Sam Maguire
Cork v Kerry - GAA Football All-Ireland Senior Championship Round 2 S James Horan: Positivity too often taking a back seat in football
Derry v Donegal - Ulster GAA Football Senior Championship Quarter-Final Tyrone the next stop on McGuinness' journey of progress 
Sport Push Notifications

By clicking on 'Sign Up' you will be the first to know about our latest and best sporting content on this browser.

Sign Up
Sport
Newsletter

Latest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers

Sign up
Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited